American Idol. and now there is five

This is the first show of the season that the contestants finally get a chance to sing 2 songs and they are able to redeem themselves if the first performance doesn't work out. and in short note they really didn't work out on the first round.
Jason Castro is too laid back and there's nothing new, Brooke simply just a mess with notes running here and there. It's not really mess up. just not interesting at all. As is the Davids. David A. did a fine job but just OK. David Cook Did a much better job but still the energy is not there. As for the shocker of the night is actually Syesha. She did a pretty good first performance. but being brush off by Simon as old fashion.

so everyone have something to proof themselves on the second try outs.
There's a little bit of harsh rumor about Paula misjudgement of the contestant have done 2 songs on the first round judgement. oh just give her a break. there's not much to fuss about it anyway. just that she is a bit blur that day. it's complicated to be told that the contestants will be judge after their 2nd performance in the beginning and then the producer decide to slot in a quick judging moment in the middle. they are just trying to remember what have happen so they won't miss anything when they are judging.

So second round..... Jason did another similar performance which is really not flaterring at all. then comes Brooke that did another songs on piano instead of guitar in her previous performance. and it's OK..... but not exactly excellent.
So David Cook is up next and finally someone really rock the house. (though I still think Syesha first performance is better.) Then came David Archuleta and he's back to his old self. belting out all the right note and note change at the right moment.
Syesha is to close the show. and the second performance though playful and right on Syesha style is just an OK performance.

According to the preformance and the likelihood of popularity votes goes there's pretty few to choose from.
1. David Archuleta
2. David Cook
3. Syesha Mercado (though I feel she did good this night but the popularity votes is just not there. being on the bottom for almost every show has just proven it.)
4. Jason Castro (because of the performance there's just too plain. if not consider the originality, he have to have another style to get by as the best performer. but he do have the majority votes.)
5. Brooke White (she just have a OK night and there's just not enough)

So that's about 2 days a go. and yesterday night. They come back to see who's the goner. and it turns out this year is the popularity contest after all.
Jason is voted through right on the first announcement.
So Jason is Safe. the Davids are definitely going through so, there's just Brooke and Syesha left.
Could this year's contest be an all Men final 3? cos by the look of it. Jason really have something charming to hold on to even with a normal performance only.

So in the end, Syesha still have a little bit of edge over Brooke and got through. So Brooke White is out. in my opinion, she should been out a bit earlier. Not that she deserve less or other deserve more. it's that she is a writter singer. which means she is not exactly the popularity type with a style that suits the show. If the are looking for a song composer or writer show then she maybe great. but a singer popularity contest is just not exact fit for a quiet musician. So, a bit fine tune on the singing, she'd be well on her way to doing great things.

And to tell the truth, the contest is getting a bit bore and boreder every week.... the performance as Randy says all the time..... jump from the sit...